Now that the holidays are rolling around I find myself mentally making checklists in my head as to the many ways I want to create Christmas magic for my four year old daughter. I want her to anticipate Santa, the elves, his reindeer, snowmen who magically come to life; the whole sha-bang. The things I remember spending Christmases with my father and his wife, Bernadette, when I was eight and had started spending my winter holiday getting ready for, participating in and basking in the afterglow in Malden, Ma, stay with me until this day. They were pitifully broke at the time and lived in a less-than-steller area in a tiny apartment building sandwiched between a bar and an auto mechanics shop. It was probably my favorite Christmas to date. They had the table sized Christmas tree with built in lights, we made our own ornaments that year, strung beaded pipe cleaners beant to look like candy canes on the tiny tree, baked sugar cookies for ourselves and of course, for Santa. We left a carrot stick our for the reindeer and left a little note for Santa thanking him for the presents and inviting him to take the cookies and milk. The next morning there was a little note back from Santa, expressing his gratitude over the baked goods, “thank you for thinking of the deer”, and how we were such good kids and he would be back next year. It made my toes tingle.
I don’t remember what we got for Christmas that year. But I distinctly remember my brother, stepmother and I sitting around the kitchen table, glue and glitter covering a five foot radius around us while we decorated ornaments. 20 years later and we still have most of them. It was the best Christmas of my life.
Their lives changed and over the years they worked their way up from part time jobs, college, to careers and the Christmases got a little more involved. They got bigger trees, real trees chopped down from local famrs. My father started a Christmas village that he added to each ear. The gifts got bigger and there were more of them. They started buying ornaments and the amount of holiday doo-dads started covering most of the house. You couldn’t sit down without a wayward ornament hook jabbing you in the ass. However two things stayed the same; the snacks we left for Santa and the note he left us for the morning.
As a kid who was raised primarily Jewish until the age of seven by my mother and grandparents I was awed by the whole North Pole concept, the guy in a red suit sneaking intit o homes and night. Much more so then anybody else I knew. And this was after I had caught my grandmother posing as the tooth fairy the year before so you would think I would be skeptical to any mystical holiday mascot that crossed my path. But again, us Jews have no-frill holidays. There is no Hanukkah Warlock of Yom Kippor Pony. We do little more than light some candles and call it a day. And after my brother accidentally set what little hair my grandmother had on fire getting overzealous with the Menorah candles even that got taken away from us. So you can see what I held Santa on a sky high pedestal.
I mean, my yearly behavior was dependent on what Santa was thinking at any given time. I didn’t get grades for my future, I got good grades for Santa! I wasn’t sure how exactly he was all knowing. I figured that was part of the elves job description, reporting on the behavior of the world’s girls and boys. I didn’t really question anything about Santa. I never wondered how he could be both in the mall and ringing a bell by a donation bucket outside at the same time. And I didn’t know a single person with a chimney. Parents stayed awake to let him in through the front door obviously.
Around the age of ten….ahem….okay I may have been half way to 12, I started to have my doubts over how real Santa may be. I am not really sure what changed but it was the same year I became aware I was one of the few girls still not wearing a bra and began kissing my bear to prepare for the day in the far, far future (is what I told myself at the time) that I would finally kiss a boy. Or a boy would want to kiss me. Whatever happened first. Puberty was starting to sneak up to me, looking over my shoulder but ducking when I turned away. I was stuck between getting my first period and still reading The Babysitter Club Book series. So that may have had something to do with it.
I wrote Santa my annual letter that year. I wrote two actually. One that I dutifully handed to my father and the other that I wrote on the sly alone in the attic guest room they now had after moving into an old but spacious two family home in the nicer neighborhood of Malden. This was the year I was finally going to test the Santa Theory. I was not ready to fully give up on the idea that he wouldn’t be piloting a sleigh over the urban jungles and country roads. I had become a skeptic, sure, but I could not walk away from this relationship unless I had the truth. This second letter was straight and to the point.
Dear Santa,
I hope this does not make you mad but I have been hearing rumors and stuff that you aren’t real and that my parents just pretend that you come into the house every Christmas Eve and write me back a note. So if you really are real you will know that I am writing this letter and you will know where I will be hiding it. If you are really real then you will write me back TO THIS LETTER ONLY! Not just the one I am leaving by the cookies. And if you are real I am really really sorry I am doing this. I just have to know so I can move on.
Love Always Heather
PS: You can write on the bottom of this letter or on the back. PSS: This doesn’t count as me being bad. But I like doing investigations as you probably know from my new business, the international Ghost Hunters Club, for which I am president.
I sealed the letter and lay it in front of my and gently placed my hand on it to get “the vibe” (I did this on tests too, placed my hand over the question to get a “vibe” on the answer. I was convinced I was psychic but still had to develop my powers. It was around this time my grades started to decline. Why study when you had supernatural abilties.) The Vibe told me that I was going to be pleasantly surprised by what I would find the next day. I hid the letter behind a heavy curtain in the small window next to the front door of the down stairs vestibule. Nobody ever had a reason to linger around down there so the chances of it being found in the next 24 hours was slim.
The next morning I awoke and ran down the stairs from the attic to the living room level of the home. I only stopped to take a quick peek to see what the gift situation looked like (it looked pretty on point) and continued down to the vestibule, where the letter still was. This was the moment of truth. The letter was still sealed but that didn’t mean anything. Maybe Santa just wanted to keep his response secret so he re-sealed it.
I was confused when I pulled out my letter and saw that nothing was written beneath my handwriting. I flipped the letter over and the page was blank. This couldn’t be possible. I flipped the letter back over and re-read everything I had written the day before just to see if maybe I had missed something, a little note in the margin, I simple signature, even corrections to my grammar and spelling. But all i saw were my own words staring back at me, the tone of the note pleading, desperate and pathetic. There was no Santa. It was all a lie and it always had been. The past few Christmases felt slightly more meaningless. I folded the letter back up and tucked it back behind the window. I walked back up the stairs to the living room where the family was starting to gather and settle, the adults with coffee in their hands, my one brother bouncing up and down, my little baby brother Sean trying to eat a ribbon.
“Santa wrote you back,” Bernadette said handing me the first letter I had written thanking Santa in advanced for the gifts and hoping that he liked the goodies. I scanned the note he wrote, the same basic stuff about how I had been good that year and thank you for the milk. Buncha bullshit is what this is, I thought. “Neat,” I responded, blinking back tears.
I went back to New Jersey shortly after New Years Eve, my year continued and I forgot about the whole Santa-not-being-real debacle. We would be spending the summer with my dad as we did every summer but in Maryland instead as that was where Bernadette’s job had relocated her. They packed up their Malden home in April and in May I got a letter in the mail.
My mom walked into the kitchen and casually tossed an envelope onto the table. “You got a letter,” she said.
“From who?” I was curious and excited. I was jealous that adults got mail on a daily basis. I never understood how they weren’t more excited over it.
My mom looked on my both the front and back of the enevolope, “No clue,” she said turning from me and rummaging around int her purse for some lost object.
I used my grandfather’s silver letter opener to open it and pulled out the letter that looked somewhat aged. Opening it I saw my handwriting and realized it was the letter that I had written to Santa and stuck behind the curtain five months earlier. But something was reflecting through it. There was a letter written on the other side in a darker, heavier ink.
Dear Heather,
Please forgive me for not getting this to you sooner. I actually had read the letter you wrote me on Christmas Eve after I got done eating those wonderful cookies and putting out your Christmas gifts but I was strapped for time and was unable to write back. Understand that it is a lot of work to get presents to all the boys and girls in the world and I am but one man. I feel horrible that I couldn’t write you back until now but rest assured I did not forget about you. I am not mad either, it was very smart of you to come up with a plan like that. Can’t wait to come by next year. You are turning into a wonderful and lovely young lady and I am very proud of you. Your dad and mom are too, they told me personally.
Love Always, Santa Clause
“What is it?” my mom asked. I handed her the letter and flatley told her Santa wrote me back. She read it silently and snorted to herself. “Looks like your father’s handwriting to me,” she said before handing me the letter back. And she was right, it did. I appreciated the effort but the damage had been done five months earlier.
Every year after that I stay up late and help wrap gifts for the rest of the family. Bernadette and I would sit side my side with rolls of tape, labels and different rolls of wrapping paper surrounding us. Every so often she would look up as I was putting a label on and say “Make sure that one says ‘From Santa’.” I would write “Santa” carefully for a gift for one of my (now) three brothers and set it aside. The next morning we would open our presents and my brothers would look up to the ceiling and say “Thank you, Santa!” rosey faced and smiling ear from ear. Two or three of my gifts would say “To Heather, From Santa” too and this trend continued well into my 20’s.
Last year was the first Christmas my daughter Sophia understood certain things regarding Christmas Eve. She had sat on Santa’s lap that year down at my husband’s hall and told him what she wanted. We made cookies and set them out with a small glass of milk and threatened her with Santa skipping over our basement apartment if she didn’t go to sleep at a decent hour. She went to bed seeing nothing under our tree to waking up and seeing a small pile of colorfully wrapped gifts to her from both myself, my husband and of course Santa. Even my husband had a present from Santa.
Santa has a stronger hold on her this year than last. Early in October I found her rooting through the side table draw.
“May I ask what you are looking for?” I asked Soph.
“I’m looking for the stamps,” she was shoulder deep in this draw, “Can you get me the stamps, Mommy?”
“What do you need stamps for?”
“I want to mail a letter,” she responded.
I am dumbfounded. This was someone who figured out how to download Netflix onto my husband’s phone and then immediately found a season of South Park to watch. The concept of snail mail was too outdated for her. “You have a letter you want to mail? To who?”
“Santa,” she said running out of the living room. She disappeared for a few minutes but then came back with one of my left over “Thank You” cards I had used for my wedding. She had what loosely represented a list scrawled out in purple crayon and had attempted to spell Santa on the small envelope. “S” was the only letter she had figured out. She held it out in front of me.
“Very nice, read it to me,” I suggest and she rattled off several items (Dream Light, pair of slippeds, My Little Pony stuff; typical four year old girl things.) “Well, I guess I better get you a stamp so you can mail it. The postman won’t pick it up if it doesn’t have postage,” I hand her a stamp from the roll I keep in our DVD case for no reason whatsoever except that is always where I keep it. I show her where the stamp goes and I tuck it into my purse. “I will drop this off at the post office tomorrow while i’m at work,” I tell her.
“You will? Tomorrow?” she asks excitedly.
“Of course, tomorrow,” I tell her,”the North Pole is far away, they don’t have trucks that go out there. It can only be delivered by dog sled. So we have to send it out ASAP,” I explain.
She nods in total agreement, silly child, because she is four and believes everything I say. Unless i am trying to get her to eat anything green. She doesn’t seem to believe me when I tell her certain foods are healthy. I wasn’t going to hold that against her. This was the year the magic of Santa was going to slap her upside the head.
I dread the day she no long believes in Santa, the day I ask her what she thinks Santa will bring her and she looks at me like i am a total asshole and says “Mom, (because one day being called ‘Mommy’ will be out the window too) Santa isn’t real.” I mourn that day already. Because I feel like no longer believing in Santa is the day that marks when your innocence starts to dissipate, you realize the things your parents tell you may not be 100% truthful, and that Christmas cheer is created within and not from a guy who could stand to eat less cookies and switch to Slim milk. The year I stopped believing in all of those Christmas creatures was the year I got my first period. And while I want my daughter to grow up, become a bright young lady, and move out of my house; I dread her growing up, becoming a bright young lady, and moving out of my house. Not believing in Santa is the first sign someone is growing up. I live for the years of her laying in bed, wondering where Santa must be right at this very moment, imaging him thinking that the cookie she made him was the best of the night, what note he would leave her, what it would say, what gifts he would leave. It is devastating to think that one day she will go to bed, not have these thoughts, wake up and think “My parents better have gotten me that phone I wanted.”
I probably have five or six years left of Santa with her and then I have my youngest, not even four months old, to play Santa with. But I can see myself ten or fifteen years from now in my living room in my house (hopefully I will be able to afford a house in New Jersey at this point) with a real Christmas tree by a bay window, my two teenage children crawling out of bed at noon to open their presents. Like my own father tradition reigns supreme and I still would have done the things he passed down to me and that I, in turn, passed down to my own children. I will have already been up for hours after having to gone to bed late the night before, wrapping presents and choosing a few to put “From Santa”. I’d have eaten more cookies than I should have, i’d have pour the milk into my coffee and have left the rest on the table. When my kids come into the room finally, rubbing sleep out of their eyes I will have hugged them both, kissing their cheeks and whispering “Merry Christmas” to both of them. I’ll have pointed out that breakfast is on the table, sit, I wil make a plate for both of you. And as both of them sit down to their bounty, I will pass a hand written note to one of the two of them and say “Look, Santa wrote you guys back.”